Authority and Age: Do They Go Hand-in-Hand?

I’ve been thinking about this idea of authority and age, in terms of business, lately. The thoughts have been spurred by some interesting feedback I’ve gotten recently (and not so recently). I’ve heard a lot of people, in my industry (online business) and back when I worked at a job, tell me directly (or indirectly, as the case may be): Shut up. I’m older and wiser than you are. I can’t listen to what you’re saying or acknowledge what you’re doing because of your age. And because of your age, I’m convinced that you couldn’t possibly add any value to this topic.

Perhaps they’re right, considering my initial response is to want to smack around anyone who hints at such a thing. Which is probably not the most mature way to think. ;) But, just for clarification here, and not because I feel like I need to justify myself to anyone (because I don’t), I’m not your average 23 year old. And that’s all you need to know.

So I’ve been pondering these questions. Do authority and age go hand-in-hand? Do people listen to and take seriously someone younger than they are who has more experience than they do? Are we subconsciously paying attention to this “older = wiser” stereotype, even if we say we aren’t? Do you have to prove yourself twice as much when you’re young? Do wisdom and age go hand-in-hand?

Here’s what I think.

Unfortunately, authority and age, and wisdom and age, both go hand-in-hand.

And I say that’s unfortunate because I feel like a lot of young people in the business world get dismissed as being near worthless because they’re not a little bit older, and thereby a little bit wiser.

A good example is my friend Erica Douglass, who recently did a post on a great blog called Get Rich Slowly. Just read the comments. Erica has done some great things in her life, and has some great wisdom to share because of it. But it seems like some people want to focus on her age and use that as a reason to discredit her. If she were 45, I don’t think her credibility, and authority on the topic in which she wrote, would have been under such attack.

Sometimes if you’re young, and you want to be taken seriously, you’re going to have to put in double the work, have double the success to show for it, and strongly make your presence known.

In the business world, if you’re older, you command a level of respect right off the bat. If you’re young, suddenly you need to try really hard to earn that respect – even if you’re running circles around others. I know that’s the game I had to play at my last job. And I’m not into playing games and wasting time – so I quit. I guess I made my presence known then.

And I don’t even think we’re aware that we’re prejudging people.

I know I’m not aware of it most of the time. But I’m becoming aware of it. I’ve made a conscious decision to judge the authority and merit of people based on their accomplishments – not their age. And I’ve been exposed to a whole host of new authorities in the online business world.

So here’s a situation for you. Let’s say two people have the same amount of experience, in blogging and social media (since we’re all probably familiar with those realms). Are you more likely to know, like, and trust the older person, or the younger person? And why?

  • Share/Bookmark

If you liked this, you might also enjoy...

  1. Why I Just Couldn’t Do the Corporate World Thing

  • http://mikejuly.com/ Mike July

    Hi Lisa,

    Interesting topic.

    I think that the scenario you've described is still present – but it isn't nearly as foremost as it once was – and will continue to fade for some time. The 'older and wiser' staple is becoming more and more fallacious as the young adults of society are considerably more savvy than their professional counterparts were at the same age. The internet has allowed our generation to grow 'wise beyond our years' at an accelerated rate – to the point that the world is quickly passing by the older people who've failed to adapt – and I am sure they feel threatened by their impending obsolescence.

    In short, don't take no shit from no one. Rock on!

    MJ

  • http://artofgreatthings.com Jeffrey Tang

    Age-based discrimination is one of the few forms of discrimination that is still tolerated (or even promoted) today. What's more, most people (including those quick to cry foul over racism or sexism) don't even give it a second thought. In the United States, for example, the law prohibits employers from discriminating against employees or potential employees on the basis of age … as long as the employee in question is over 40. No protections for younger people.

    Thank you for writing on this topic; it's too often ignored.

  • http://www.mikeslife.org Mike CJ

    Even from my now “old” viewpoint, I agree with you. And I well remember the frustration that sometimes people weren't taking me seriously when I first started in business.

    It's not right, and it shouldn't happen, but it is a simple fact of human nature that age endows you with a perceived wisdom and gravity that youth doesn't. I don't think there's any way around it to be honest.

    I think you have to resign yourself to overcoming it by being more professional and working a little harder.

    You face the double disadvantage of being both young and a woman. It's not fair, but it's what you've got.

    I so, so hope this isn't patronising, but you're doing a pretty damn good job, Lisa.

  • http://www.mikeslife.org Mike CJ

    I need to add something to that comment! The other side of the coin is that your own perception of yourself doesn't change as you get older, it's other people's perception of you that changes.

    I still don't think I'm old enough or wise enough to be running a business, and I still worry every day that the rest of the world is going to realize it!

  • http://www.notaproblog.com Jordan Cooper

    Lisa, I agree with you completely that people will discriminate based on age by default. Whether it is right or wrong is irrelevant – it's just human nature tendencies & perceptions you have to deal with regardless.

    As someone who did embark in many entrepreneurial activities in my teenage years, I can tell you this from first-hand experience. I'm convinced that many kids inhibit themselves from pursuing their passion at a young age because of this negative perception. Constantly being forced into structured education and a regimented path of supposed “success” – it's killing the pure initiative in a lot of them.

    This is why I'm sick of the question adults pose to kids “what do you want do be when you grow up?” My attitude is “what do you want to be now?” and then encourage them to do just that.

  • http://janebradbury.com/ Jane Bradbury

    I read Erica's post and the comments yesterday and felt bad for her; but I guess she'll have a tough skin and not be too damaged. I was amazed how people completely missed the point of her outsourcing, and berated her for not giving to charity (although that's none of our business) and the vilification for using a Filipina lady? I'd say unbelievable, but it isn't.

    If I had Erica's money I'd outsource my daily life too. We already do that with the cleaning and the garden, but I'd love a chef! And you know what? I'd get away with it because I'm disabled, always good for the 'Oh well, she can't do it herself,' sympathy vote! It is quite true I can't do it myself, but even if I could I'd do what Erica's done.

    At your age Lisa, I wasn't the average either; life experiences made me old before my time, in some ways. I'm 23 years older than you now, but I can recognise the wisdom you have already, and as for knowledge? Well, you know far more than I do and that's great. I'll follow you around quite happily, picking up tips. :o )

  • kimdoyal

    Hi Lisa,
    While I think I'm somewhere 'in between'….I can specifically remember when I was in a management position when I was 22 and an employee of mine (in her late 40's or early 50's) told me I was being 'sassy' with the tone in which I explained something…….excuse me? (sarcastic maybe…sassy? no)
    But I digress……
    Unfortunately, what you're talking about is definitely true. The only thing I can say as I've gotten older is that I've learned more about myself and have grown as an individual…..does that make me an authority on things? Depends…..my life yes…anyone else? No thanks.
    One of my favorite quotes (may have been Wayne Dyer) is “What you think of me is none of my business”.
    LOVE the 'Bloggers Resource'!
    Thanks,
    Kim

  • daverowley

    Hi Lisa,

    I've experienced what you're talking about and it's definitely true. When I was 19 (a long time ago *sigh*) I got promoted as a supervisor over people in their 30's and 40's and it didn't go down well at all. It's wrong and it's difficult to deal with. If a young person sticks their head up and excels people take potshots at them. Of course, if they don't then they're likely to be dismissed as a slacker.

    Here's the thing though–now I'm in my 40's and building my own on-line business and it's an entirely different arena. I've had to take a crash course in negotiating Social Media and most experts are a lot younger than me, and I've learnt a lot from some of these people. I think the current rapid turnover of knowledge and incredible pace of change has done a lot to wipe out the benefits that age used to have. If you're in your 20's now, you've grown up being accustomed to this incredible rate of change, that capacity to adapt is a priceless asset in an environment that is constantly shifting.

  • daverowley

    Hi Lisa,

    I've experienced what you're talking about and it's definitely true. When I was 19 (a long time ago *sigh*) I got promoted as a supervisor over people in their 30's and 40's and it didn't go down well at all. It's wrong and it's difficult to deal with. If a young person sticks their head up and excels people take potshots at them. Of course, if they don't then they're likely to be dismissed as a slacker.

    Here's the thing though–now I'm in my 40's and building my own on-line business and it's an entirely different arena. I've had to take a crash course in negotiating Social Media and most experts are a lot younger than me, and I've learnt a lot from some of these people. I think the current rapid turnover of knowledge and incredible pace of change has done a lot to wipe out the benefits that age used to have. If you're in your 20's now, you've grown up being accustomed to this incredible rate of change, that capacity to adapt is a priceless asset in an environment that is constantly shifting.

blog comments powered by Disqus